Scenario 1
Maria, 48, drives 22 miles each way from Corning to her Tehama County government job in Red Bluff on I-5
- 1
Month 1
Maria paid $168/mo for full coverage on her 2018 Honda CR-V through her prior carrier. Clean record, continuous insurance for 6 years.
$168/mo
- 2
Month 2
Ran the 30+ carrier panel with ZIP 96021. Progressive quoted comparable $50K/$100K/$50K liability with $1,000 collision deductible at $118/mo after good-driver 20% discount.
$118/mo
- 3
Month 3
Stacked good-driver −20%, paperless −5%, paid-in-full −8%. Maria paid the half-year premium upfront.
$88/mo
- 4
Month 6
Added low-mileage credit (under 14,000 mi/yr verified) −5% and multi-policy −8% after bundling renters coverage.
$78/mo
- 5
Month 9
Renewed at the same rate. No claims, no surcharges. I-5 deer strike on October drive: comprehensive claim, no surcharge.
$78/mo
- 6
Month 12
Annual savings vs prior carrier: $1,080 ($90/mo × 12). Same coverage, same vehicle, same I-5 commute.
$76/mo
